I kissed a girl and I liked it then I went to hell - Plenty of room for love

Dave Allison, pastor of Havens Corners Church in Blacklick, Ohio put this rather aggressive sign outside his church:
Then, after numerous emails from passers by, he changed the wording, saying about the first version: "There was no room on the sign to talk about love and forgiveness, simply the consequence."
That's odd, because I managed to fit in all these words:

And please, if you want to attack the lesbian community, pick a focus that we actually embrace - i.e. Not Katy Perry.